Her Excellency Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo
Republic of the Philippines
Malacanang, Manila

Dear President Arroyo:

We–members of the Coalition to Stop Child Detention Through Restorative Justice composed of 26 organizations nationwide–respectfully demand that the Office of the President immediately stop the barbaric, systematic, organized, and wide scale crime being committed with impunity by officers of the Philippine National Police (PNP) against 52,000 child prisoners.

These police officers–who are acting under the President’s control and supervisory authority–flout the law by locking up children with adult crime suspects in police stations and headquarters as a matter of standard operating procedure all over the country, save for Cebu City. This happens over extended periods and prior to their turnover to the Bureau of Jail Management and Penology by virtue of court-issued commitment orders. Routinely locking up children, upon arrest, in filthy jails swarming with adult crime suspects constitutes cruelty, torture, and abuse. It subjects them to conditions inimical to their development.

This is punishable under Article VI, Section 10(a) of Republic Act 7610 or An Act Providing for Stronger Deterrence and Special Protection against Child Abuse, Exploitation and Discrimination, and for Other Purposes. According to Article I, Section 3(b) of this law, child abuse covers “(p)sychological and physical abuse, neglect, cruelty, sexual abuse and emotional maltreatment.” Child abuse also embraces “(a)ny act by deeds or words which debases, degrades or demeans the intrinsic worth and dignity of a child as a human being.”

Through the chain of command, the police officers are wantonly committing this continuing crime under the President’s implicit, if not direct, orders.

The President controls and supervises the Secretary of Interior and Local Governments. The Interior Secretary, in turn, supervises and controls these PNP lawbreakers. In the final analysis, therefore, the President–by virtue of the principle of command responsibility–bears criminal responsibility for abetting and indirectly perpetrating, as well as perpetuating this institutionalized hooliganism.

For tacitly acquiescing, consenting, and authorizing, hence, being ultimately “responsible for other conditions prejudicial to the child’s development,” the President becomes liable for violating Article VI, Section 10(a) of RA 7610. For effectively abetting this widespread form of child torture, cruelty, and abuse–despite Your Excellency’s actual knowledge or being in a position to know about this prevalent crime against children of the poorest of the poor and Your Excellency’s positive duty to prevent and stop this monstrosity, as well as to punish violators�the President, for being a “public officer,” could be slapped with a 12-year jail term under Article XII, Section 31(e) of RA 7610.

The President cannot evade criminal liability, by hiding under the mantle of sovereign immunity from suit, for egregious human rights violations such as this bizarre form of torture and crimes against humanity.

Atty. Perfecto Caparas
Coalition to Stop Child Detention Through Restorative Justice
Email: coalition[at]stopchilddetention[dot]com


Isang e-zine para sa mga kabataang Pilipino ang Tinig.com. Naglalathala ito ng mga personal na sanaysay, tula, dula, maikling kuwento, balita at lathalain, komentaryo tungkol sa pambansang usapin, at iba...

Join the Conversation

1 Comment

  1. Disyembre 18, 2005

    Madam Gloria Macapagal Arroyo,

    Magandang araw po! Financial Aid scholar (50% tution fee) po ako sa Assumption College Makati. Sa darating na taon hindi ko po alam kung makakapasok pa ako doon depende nalang po kung bibigyan ako ng full scholarship ng Assumption. Ngunit ang mas mahalaga po sa akin ngayon ay gumaling ang aking ama. Mahal na mahal po nami lahat ang aming ama dahil napaka-buti niya. Kung maari po sanang makahingi ng tulong sa inyo na pambayad sa mga gamot at iba pa pong kailangan ng aming ama. Ngayong pasko nais ko po sanang sama-sama kaming pamilya ngunit nag-kasakit po ang aming ama. Simula noong Nobyembre 3, 2005 ang aking ama na si Ricardo Bernardo J. Santiago, Sr. ay nasa ospital sa Perpetual Help Medical Center Las Piñas. Ayon sa doktor, siya ay maysakit na Status Post Arrest seconday to AMI anteroseptal wall, UTI, DM2, HPN, Diabetes at Pneumonia. Malaking-malaki na po ang kinakailangan namang bayaran. Dalawa po kaming mag-kapatid at walang trabaho ang nanay ko. Nais ko po sanang humingi ng tulong sa inyo na makahingi po ng pambayad para makalabas kami ng ospital. Kung kani-kanino na rin po kami nanghihingi ng tulong para pabili ng kanyang maraming gamot. Miyembro na po kami ng Jonelta na nagbibigay ng discount sa gamot ngunit hindi pa rin o sapat iyon. Nasa ward ho ang kwarto namin dati ngunit pinalipat kami sa semi-private room dahil lalo lang daw pong lalala ang kondisyon ng tatay ko pag hindi siya nailipat dahil sa inpeksyon na dulot ng ibang may sakit. Humingi na kami ng tulong sa PCSO ngunit hanggang ngayon ay wala pa rin pong kasiguraduhan kung may ibibigay sila. Nag-mamakaawa po ako sa inyo ay kung maari ay tulungan po ang amin ama sa mga kailangan nya para gumaling at marami pa pong pasko ang pag-saluhan namin.
    Maraming salamat po!


    Princess B. Santiago

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.