My
Teacher, Franz
By Danton Remoto
Lodestar
The Philippine
Star
August 5, 2002
Francisco
"Franz" Arcellana was my teacher. Like many writers, I
first read him before I met him. On my own, I had read "The
Mats" and "The Flowers of May" when I was a young
and sullen undergrad at the Ateneo. Instead of reading my books
on Financial Accounting and Business Statistics, I sat on the table
beside the PS 9991 shelves in the Rizal Library every afternoon,
and read the books of Filipino writers. One day, I said to myself,
keeping the secret deep in my heart, one day I will also write a
book.
I
liked the subtlety of "The Mats," how it showed that at
the core of the Filipino is his or her love for family. The word
"Recuerdo" woven on the mat for the dead daughter captured
this vividly. And "The Flowers of May," which won a Palanca
Award in 1952, isn’t it in a way the flip side of "The
Mats," since it talked about the death of Victoria recalled
just as the rains of May began to sweep the land?
In
1982 I applied for the UP Writers’ Workshop and Franz Arcellana
was its director. The workshop then was as lively as it is now,
but messier. Some of the panelists did not discuss the texts at
hand but talked about their travels in Russia. Others wondered aloud
why the writers-to-be were not writing about the poor, in Tagalog.
It got so bad that one day I stood up and said I can only write
about the middle-class, because that was where I belonged, and when
I wrote in Tagalog I had my Vicassan Dictionary beside me. But Franz
- great good gracious God Franz was there - he spoke clearly and
firmly and said that the only thing we have to do as young writers
is to write the poem or the story only we can write. And that we
can write in any language we are comfortable with, whether that
is English or Tagalog or Cebuano or Pangalatok. Then and now when
I think of Franz I think of a prophet atop a mountain, white hair
like flame, his words hissing in the wind.
Those
words saved me when I came back to Ateneo and began graduate school.
After Ateneo, I wrote speeches for a government office and children’s
stories for a publishing house. It was the height of the Marcos
dictatorship. When my father lost his trading firm I had to look
for a good job and ended up editing the plenary sessions of the
Interim Batasang Pambansa. It paid well, and I was mightily entertained
by assemblymen who spoke lines like these: "I demand an investigation
into the national airlines because their airplanes always collapse."
But
every afternoon, I would go home in an aircon shuttle bus in my
beautiful barong. And when I looked outside I saw the sun beginning
to sink and a deep, inexplicable sadness always threatened to drown
me. I must write again, I remember the words forming themselves
inside me, because if I don’t, I will end up fat and wealthy
and immensely sad.
I
returned to graduate school at the Ateneo, and that summer my first
teacher was Franz.
He
taught Fiction Writing and came and went to school in his old, reliable
Beetle, which had an Apple Macintosh sticker on the windshield and
books and papers on the backseat. He always wore cool, long-sleeved
shirts, untucked, and that trademark eyeglasses. For the first story
discussed in the workshop, he asked us to comment on the word or
punctuation mark used by the writer, one student per word or punctuation
mark. The first word was "The" and the student in the
front row said it was "a definite article." Franz quickly
added, "That’s the word Hemingway suggested you use as
the first word for your work - when you can’t begin a story,
or you are continuing your novel." It took us five days to
discuss one story. I haven’t been to a workshop where the
works were discussed in such a, ahhh, microscopic way.
One
smart aleck in class asked, when we were about to discuss the second
story: "Are we going to talk about it one word or punctuation
mark per student again?"
Franz
smiled his gently avuncular smile, then said, "No."
The
same smart aleck also walked out of the class after his story was
discussed. One scene in his story showed a baby slipping from the
hand of the nurse carrying it. The baby’s head is bashed on
the floor. When Franz asked what is the point of the scene, smarty
said: "But it happened in our hospital in Cagayan de Oro City!"
Franz
said that not because it happened in real life, it could happen
in the world of fiction. Fiction is governed by rules autonomous
from that of the real world. Perhaps it was way over the head of
smarty, for pretty soon, he was standing up and leaving the room.
Too
bad for him, because he failed to see the point in any writing workshop.
It will not teach you how to write; it will teach you the attitude
you must take toward writing. What are these attitudes? That the
story, the poem, the essay or the novel has to be written, whether
the world is ending or your heart is breaking. That the writer begins
again and again when he writes, such that a flotilla of awards means
nothing in the end. That Time, that great and severe arbiter, is
the only judge that can tell whether you will be read 100 years
from now, or be relegated as a footnote in the literary history.
I
submitted old stories for the class and wrote new ones, and was
surprised myself by the sexual content of the new stories I wrote.
Franz could read your story and draw its structure on the board,
such was the depth and clarity of his mind. One day, Franz took
me aside said he was willing to discuss my stories privately not
because he wanted to censor, but we would take more than a week
explaining to the under-grad students what those body fluids and
subtexts mean. Oh Franz he can be wicked, too, like one day when
he told me he opens the middle page of a newly-bought book, to inhale
its "virginity." Or weird, as when one student told him
he liked the story "Divide by Two" that Franz had written
and he flew into a short but magnificent rage, telling us loudly,
"I hate that story! I hate that story!"
But
through the years, he set many young writers on the road. Or even
not-so-young ones. In his first book Oldtimers, Butch Dalisay thanked
Franz "for seeing me home." Eric Gamalinda also told me,
over cappuccino and latté in Chelsea, that the old man helped
him a lot when Eric decided to go back to school, and write fiction.
In 1994, Franz attended the launching of Ladlad, the gay anthology
that Neil Garcia and I had edited, the first in this Catholic and
conservative country. It was a difficult week. You must remember
that my father is a retired military officer and my mother a teacher,
and both are Catolico cerrado. Suddenly I had rashes all over because
of the launching but when the day came, my mentors were there. Franz
and Bien Lumbera and Rio Alma showed up. I was glad.
Sometimes
I visited Franz in the Faculty Center of UP to ask him to sign a
book, or write letters of recommendation, or just to chat. He would
be sitting there, amidst a whirlwind of old books, covering them
all carefully with white bond paper. U2 would be playing in the
background, a cassette tape given by one his students.
One
of the poems that Eman Lacaba wrote was called "After Franz
Arcellana." Franz got a Smith-Mundt grant in Creative Writing
in 1956 and he visited the poet Richard Eberhart at Princeton University
in New Jersey. Franz told Eman about this. Eman assumed the voice
and persona of Franz in this beautiful work, which is included in
Salvaged Poems.
"In
the spring of ’56 I went to see Richard Eberhart./ Have you
been, he asked, in a Quaker graveyard?/ No, I said. He took me to
one outside Princeton./ Spring was just beginning; cold the high
noon./ Still went from the thaw the ground, like green fire/ The
neophyte grass, the air miraculously clear./ Under the cypresses
and elms, as we wove in and out/ Among the mounds of Friends, the
poet said: Note/ The graves are unmarked. At their heads are stones/
But no names. Just stones. Just any-shape stones."
URL:
http://www.philstar.com/philstar/search_content.asp?article=88019
|

Home
Profile
Photos
This site
Guestbook
|